IRS Insider: What Auditors Really Look For (and What They Actually Care About)
- Lauren Twitchell
- Oct 23, 2025
- 4 min read
The word audit scares people. Most imagine someone in a dark suit combing through every receipt they’ve ever touched.
But after years inside the IRS, I can tell you: auditors aren’t hunting for perfection—they’re looking for proof.
When your numbers make sense and your records back them up, the conversation ends quickly.When they don’t, that’s when the questions begin.
Here’s what auditors actually look for—and what matters more than you think.
1. Consistency Across All Records
The first thing an auditor checks isn’t your receipts—it’s consistency.
They compare your return to:
Prior-year filings
Industry averages
1099s and 1099-Ks issued under your name
W-2 or payroll filings (if applicable)
State filings or sales tax reports
If your numbers tell a consistent story, they move on.If your income drops 40% while expenses double—or if your 1099-K shows more income than your return—that’s when they start asking for documentation.
What this means for you:
Reconcile your books monthly so totals always match.
Compare your return to your 1099s before filing.
Keep a short written explanation of big year-to-year changes (e.g., equipment purchase, new contractor, temporary slowdown).
Auditors like clarity. If your records make logical sense, they won’t waste time digging.
2. Proof of Income
Under IRM 4.10.3, auditors must verify that income is “accurately reported and properly supported.”
They’ll review:
Bank deposits
Payment processor reports (Stripe, Square, PayPal)
1099-K or 1099-NEC forms
Customer invoices or sales ledgers
The biggest red flag? Unreported deposits—especially cash.
Auditors often perform a “bank deposits analysis,” totaling every deposit and comparing it to reported income. If deposits exceed reported sales, they’ll ask why.
Your best defense:
Record gross income before fees or refunds.
Label non-income deposits clearly (e.g., “transfer from savings,” “owner contribution”).
Keep invoices and receipts that match every deposit.
If you can explain each inflow, you’ve already won half the battle.
3. Documentation for Deductions
Most audits aren’t about income—they’re about deductions.
The IRS doesn’t assume you’re lying. They assume you might be missing proof.
Auditors want to see that every deduction is:
Ordinary and necessary for your business (IRC §162).
Clearly documented with amount, date, payee, and purpose.
They don’t expect elaborate spreadsheets—just credible support.
Examples:
Receipts or invoices showing business purpose.
Mileage logs (not guesses).
Credit card statements with clear vendor descriptions.
Proof of payment (bank or PayPal transaction).
If you can match an expense to a real business need, you’re fine. If it looks personal, expect questions.
4. Separation of Business and Personal
Contrary to myth, the IRS doesn’t know you’re mixing expenses until they audit you.
Once they review your bank statements, they’ll separate the business from the personal.If they find personal spending charged as deductions, they’ll disallow them immediately.
Why this matters:
It reduces your credibility.
It forces you to explain legitimate business charges twice.
It slows down the entire exam.
Fix it before they find it:
Use separate bank and credit accounts.
Pay yourself a transfer instead of swiping the business card for personal expenses.
Label every charge as you go.
Clean separation = faster, simpler audits.
5. Mathematical Accuracy
It sounds basic, but arithmetic errors flag more returns than you’d think.
IRS systems check for mismatched totals between forms—Schedule C, 1040, or business returns. A $50 rounding difference won’t trigger an audit, but a $5,000 discrepancy might.
Your move:Let software do the math, but verify manually that income and expense summaries match your source records. The less correction the IRS has to do, the smoother your file looks.
6. Patterns of “Too Perfect”
This one surprises people: sometimes, returns that look too clean draw attention.
Example:
Round numbers everywhere ($5,000, $10,000, $15,000).
Identical deductions every year.
No variance in income despite market changes.
To auditors, that looks estimated, not documented.They expect some fluctuation—business is messy.
The takeaway:Real records have texture. Don’t round, don’t guess, and don’t smooth out the story. Accuracy beats neatness every time.
7. Signs of Hobby Activity
For sole proprietors and side hustlers, auditors pay close attention to profit motive.
If you’ve reported losses several years in a row, they’ll ask:
Do you run the activity like a business (advertising, bookkeeping, separate accounts)?
Are you trying to make a profit?
Do you depend on the income to live?
If the answers lean hobby, your deductions could be limited.
Protect yourself by:
Keeping business-like records.
Tracking marketing efforts.
Setting goals for profitability.
Even if you love what you do, your books should prove it’s not just for fun.
What Auditors Don’t Care About
Let’s clear up some myths.
Auditors don’t care about:
Fancy software or reports.
How small your business is.
Whether your desk is messy.
They care about one thing: whether your records can back up your return.
That’s it.
The Audit Mindset: Fact, Not Fear
Every IRS audit starts the same way: a computer identifies an inconsistency.That doesn’t mean guilt—it means verification.
Agents follow the Internal Revenue Manual step by step. They document what they reviewed, what you provided, and whether your records are adequate.
When your numbers line up, they close the case.When they don’t, they expand it.
Your goal isn’t perfection—it’s transparency.
A Quick Real-Life Example
A small contractor I worked with was audited because his income jumped by 30% in one year.The auditor wanted proof that his expenses kept pace.
Because he had clean, reconciled books and detailed receipts, the review ended in three weeks—no adjustments.
Had he waited until the letter arrived to organize everything, it could’ve dragged on for months.
Auditors aren’t out to get you. They’re out to verify your story.
If your return is consistent, your numbers make sense, and your records support your claims, the story ends quickly.
👉 Audit-proof your books before anyone asks. Reconcile monthly, separate your spending, and save your receipts.Clarity isn’t just protection—it’s power.
No judgment. No fluff. Just clean books.
Comments