Why Etsy Fees Mess Up Your Profit Picture (And How to Fix It)
- Lauren Twitchell
- 6 days ago
- 3 min read
Selling on Etsy can feel empowering—you upload your listings, customers find you, and sales notifications light up your phone. But then you look at your bank account, and the deposit doesn’t line up with what you thought you made.
Here’s why: Etsy’s fee structure is more complicated than most sellers realize.
If you’re not tracking correctly, you’re underestimating expenses, misreading profit, and sometimes even underreporting income. And if the IRS ever looks at your numbers? Forget it—messy Etsy records are an easy audit headache.
This post will break down:
What Etsy fees really include.
Why they distort your profit picture.
A no-fluff way to fix your bookkeeping and see the truth.
The Many Layers of Etsy Fees
Etsy doesn’t just take one cut. They take several. And unless you’ve studied their seller handbook closely, you might not realize just how many.
Here are the main ones:
Listing Fee: $0.20 per item. Every time you create or renew a listing.
Transaction Fee: 6.5% of the sale price (including shipping).
Payment Processing Fee: Varies by country; in the U.S., 3% + $0.25 per transaction.
Advertising Fees (optional): Offsite Ads or Etsy Ads, percentages or daily caps.
Other Fees: Currency conversion, regulatory fees, refund processing.
Let’s put this into numbers. You sell a handmade mug for $30 plus $6 shipping = $36 total.
Transaction fee: $2.34
Processing fee: $1.33
Listing fee: $0.20
Total fees: $3.87
Your net deposit: $32.13.
If you only record deposits as “sales,” you’re missing both income and expenses.
Why Etsy Fees Distort Your Profit Picture
Most Etsy sellers check their bank account or Etsy deposit summary and think that’s their “income.” Wrong. That’s net after fees.
Here’s why that’s a problem:
You’re underreporting sales. The IRS wants gross sales, not what hit your bank. Etsy even reports this on a 1099-K.
You’re ignoring expenses. Fees disappear into deposits, never logged as expenses. That means your profit looks artificially low.
You can’t calculate margins. If you don’t see fees separately, you’ll never know if your products are actually profitable.
Pricing mistakes snowball. Sellers underprice items because they forget to factor in fees, then wonder why they’re broke.
The IRS Angle
Here’s the kicker: Etsy reports your gross sales to the IRS on Form 1099-K. If you report only net deposits, the IRS sees a mismatch. And trust me—that mismatch is an audit magnet.
The IRS doesn’t care that Etsy already skimmed fees. They want to see gross income reported, with fees logged as deductible expenses. If you’re skipping that step, you’re waving a red flag.
The Fix: A No-Fluff System for Etsy Bookkeeping
The good news? You don’t need an MBA to clean this up. You just need to record correctly.
Here’s the step-by-step:
Step 1: Track Gross Sales
Log the full sale amount, including shipping, before Etsy fees are deducted.
Step 2: Record Fees as Expenses
Break out transaction, processing, and listing fees. Treat them like any other business expense.
Step 3: Reconcile Deposits
Match Etsy’s payout reports to your bank deposits weekly. Net deposits should equal gross sales minus fees.
Step 4: Review Margins Once fees are separated, you’ll see if your pricing is actually covering costs.
Step 5: Adjust Pricing If Needed
Don’t price blindly. Factor in Etsy’s cut so you’re not losing profit on every sale.
A Story From the Cleanup Desk
One Etsy seller I worked with (let’s call her Sarah) made beautiful handmade jewelry. She thought she was making $2,000 per month.
When we did her cleanup, here’s what we found:
She was logging deposits as sales, not gross.
Fees were vanishing into thin air.
Ads were eating into her margins.
Reality? She was bringing in $2,500 in sales, paying nearly $500 in fees, and netting $2,000. Her books showed $2,000 in “income” and zero in “expenses.”
That meant two things:
She was underreporting income to the IRS.
She was undervaluing her profit margin.
Once we cleaned up her books, she had clarity. She adjusted her pricing, cut back on ads that weren’t converting, and finally saw her true numbers.
Why This Matters for Sellers
Etsy isn’t a hobby anymore—it’s a business. And businesses live or die on margins.
If you’re not tracking fees properly:
You’re leaving yourself open to IRS trouble.
You’re making business decisions in the dark.
You’re probably underpricing your work.
The Tool That Helps
At Zero Fluff Books, we’ve built templates specifically for Etsy sellers. They track gross sales, fees, and deposits in one clean sheet. It’s simple, repeatable, and designed for sellers who don’t want to waste hours on bookkeeping.
Final Word
Etsy fees aren’t the enemy. Ignoring them is.
The platform gives you reports—you just need to use them correctly. Track gross, log fees as expenses, and reconcile deposits. That’s it.
And if your books are already messy? That’s where cleanup comes in. Zero Fluff Books untangles the chaos so you can focus on making, not math.
Comments